How Downtown Boards Should Track and Measure Success
Downtown boards need concrete metrics to measure revitalization progress. Attendance estimates aren’t enough.

Downtown boards spend months putting together vision plans and strategy documents. Then they spend years talking about carrying them out. Most never measure whether any of it is working [1].

Laziness isn’t the problem. Measurement takes discipline. Good numbers take work to gather, and they make boards face things they’d rather not hear. A board can celebrate six new businesses opening downtown. Measurement shows whether those businesses can last, or whether they’re just replacing failed businesses at about the same rate. The pattern tells you more than the headline count.

Measurement forces you to diagnose problems instead of ignoring them.

Most downtown boards run on assumption and hope. We think our streetscape project is creating activity. We hope our event strategy is building foot traffic. We assume our incentive programs are bringing in the right businesses. Without measurement, assumptions are all we have.

That gets expensive. Boards put public money, staff time, and their own attention into strategies that may not be working. They miss problems until those problems turn into crises. They can’t tell whether to keep going or change course. And they can’t prove their work to skeptical elected officials who control their budgets.

Good measurement fixes all of that.

The Core Metrics

Your board should track three categories of metrics: property and development, business and tenant, and usage and activity. They don’t all carry the same weight. Property metrics count the most.

Property metrics include average property value, property value trends by block or sector, number of properties for sale, time on market, property tax base growth, and vacancy rates by property type. They tell you whether private investors think downtown is worth putting money into.

If property values are rising and vacancy is declining, revitalization is working. If not, your strategy needs adjustment.

When property values go up and vacancy goes down, investors are buying properties and filling them. That brings jobs, tax revenue, and activity. If property values are flat or falling and vacancy is rising, the opposite is happening [1].

Your city assessment office can give you most of this data. It’s not glamorous, but you can count on it.

Business and tenant metrics include the number of occupied ground-floor retail spaces, number of operating businesses, business formation rate, business failure rate, and average business tenure. These tell you whether businesses are able to keep themselves going.

Usage and activity metrics include foot traffic counts at key intersections, vehicle counts, event attendance, downtown residential population, and late-evening activity. These tell you whether people are using downtown.

The mistake most boards make is looking at usage metrics alone. They count event attendance and celebrate foot traffic. Traffic without property value growth and businesses that last is empty activity. Measure usage, but treat it as a secondary indicator.

Gathering the Data

Property and business numbers are easier to get than you might think. Your city assessor has property value and tax data. Your chamber of commerce or business tax office can track business formation and operation. If you keep a downtown property inventory, you’re already tracking occupied and vacant spaces.

Usage metrics take more effort. Many boards buy foot traffic counters that pick up body heat or motion and log counts around the clock. These cost $5,000 to $15,000 per unit, and they give you solid baseline data. Put them at key intersections, and don’t only use them during events. Everyday traffic tells you as much as peak traffic.

Count event attendance seriously. Don’t estimate. Use actual gates or ticket scans. Ask people where they came from so you can separate local from regional visitors. An event that only draws locals who already come downtown is worth less than one that brings new people in.

For business metrics, build a spreadsheet. Track every ground-floor retail space in your target district. Note the tenant, the rent rate if you have it, the lease start date, and notes on the business. Update it every quarter. That gives you a live record of business activity instead of guesses.

For residential population, track demolitions, conversions, and new construction. Many city planning departments can provide this data. You should know whether downtown’s residential population is growing or shrinking.

Establishing Baselines and Targets

Don’t measure at random. Before you start, set a baseline. What’s the current property value? What’s the current vacancy rate? How many businesses are downtown right now? Write it all down formally.

Then set targets. If the current average property value is $500,000, what do you want it to be in three years, or five? If vacancy is 20 percent, what’s your target? If you have twelve operating businesses today, how many do you want in three years?

Targets should be realistic and ambitious, and they should tie back to your strategy. If your strategy is to grow the residential population, your target might be fifty new residential units over five years. If your strategy is to eliminate ground-floor vacancy, your target might be zero vacant ground-floor space.

Write down the baseline and the targets. Make them public. Revisit them every year, and adjust them if your strategy changes.

Reporting and Accountability

Measuring only helps if you share the results. Your board should publish an annual dashboard that shows progress against your targets. Make it public. Share it with elected officials. Use it in grant applications and funding requests.

The dashboard should cover all three categories: property value and vacancy, business metrics, and usage metrics. Show trends over time instead of single snapshots, and compare each one to its target. If you’re ahead, say so. If you’re behind, say that too, along with what you’re doing about it.

Reporting forces accountability. If vacancy is rising and business formation has stalled, the board can’t hide behind a hopeful story. You have to deal with the real problem.

What Metrics Should Not Be

Skip vanity metrics. Event attendance counts if the events bring in business revenue and new customers. Attendance by itself, with no effect on business, doesn’t tell you much. A downtown with packed events and flat or rising vacancy has an entertainment problem. It doesn’t have an economic development solution.

Skip surveys and self-reported satisfaction unless they track specific changes in behavior. Asking visitors whether they “feel safe” tells you less than tracking whether violent crime is going down. Asking merchants whether they’re “satisfied” tells you less than tracking whether business tenure is getting longer.

Don’t mix short-term activity with long-term outcomes. A spike in foot traffic on event day is a short-term metric. Property value growth and businesses that last are long-term metrics. Report both, but know which one your strategy actually depends on.

Using Metrics to Drive Change

The real reason to measure is to make better decisions about strategy.

If your property values are growing on one block and stalled everywhere else, that tells you where to focus redevelopment. If your business numbers show retail getting replaced by services and entertainment, that tells you market demand is changing. If certain kinds of space are harder to fill, that tells you where incentive programs should aim.

A board that measures quarterly and makes strategy adjustments based on data outperforms a board that measures annually or not at all.

A board that measures every quarter and adjusts its strategy based on the data is going to outperform a board that measures once a year or not at all [2].

Questions Your Board Should Ask

What is your current average downtown property value? If you don’t know, find out this week.

What is your current downtown vacancy rate? For ground-floor retail specifically.

How many ground-floor retail businesses were in downtown five years ago? How many are there now?

Do you track foot traffic? If not, should you?

Have you set explicit targets for the next three years? Are they written down and public?

Bottom Line

Measurement is unglamorous work. It doesn’t make headlines or give the community anything to celebrate. It’s how professional boards operate, though. It tells you whether you’re moving toward your goals or just staying busy, and it builds accountability inside the board and with elected officials.

A downtown board that measures carefully, reports openly, and adjusts its strategy based on data is a professional organization. A board that doesn’t measure is spending money and hoping for the best. Over the long run, the gap between those two shows up in the results.


Frequently Asked Questions

Property value and vacancy rates are the leading indicators. If property values are rising and vacancy is declining, revitalization is working. Foot traffic and event attendance can grow without any economic impact that sticks. Property value shows whether private investors believe downtown will hold up over the long term.

Quarterly at minimum, with a formal report once a year. Some metrics, like property values, change slowly. Others, like vacancy rates, can shift with the seasons. Set a regular schedule and stick to it. Being consistent counts for more than checking often.

That's the whole point of measuring. If vacancy is rising or property values are flat, your current strategy isn't working, and you need to figure out why. More events and marketing won't fix a downtown with poor walkability or deteriorating buildings. Measurement makes you deal with the real problems.


References

  1. Georgia Department of Community Affairs. (2021). Tax Allocation District (TAD) Basics and Best Practices. State of Georgia. https://dca.georgia.gov/search/results
  2. Georgia Department of Community Affairs. (2022). Technology Implementation and Vendor Management for Municipalities. State of Georgia. https://dca.georgia.gov